Show Transcript and Show Notes for The Palimpsest Society a Bi-Weekly Call of Cthulhu Actual Play Podcast!

Between each scenario, join us for Sanity Check-In, our behind-the-scenes conversations where the cast reflects on the mysteries, choices, characters, and creeping horrors shaping the Palimpsest Society.

In the first Palimpsest Society Sanity Check, the cast steps out from behind their characters to reflect on The Initiation. From skill growth and sanity recovery to the candle, the well, and the unsettling presence waiting below, they unpack the choices that shaped the story and the unexpected connections forming between their investigators.

Join Ryan, Alicia, Seth, Erin, and Michael for a candid conversation about collaborative storytelling, historical horror, and the question at the heart of every investigation: when something is frightening, is it truly a monster or is it asking to be understood?

Connect with the Crew on Instagram:

  • Ryan McLaughlin (Keeper) โ€“ย @thepalimpsestsociety
  • Erin Hippel (Merritt Vale) โ€“ย  @thepalimpsestsociety
  • Michael Hall Lindsay (Captain Ashcroft) โ€“ย @warsonggames
  • Alicia Figliuolo (Dr. Prudence Abercombie) โ€“ย @aliciafigliuolo
  • Seth Dellinger (Ezra Merrick) โ€“ @sethdellingervo

Welcome to The Palimpsest Society

Join us every other Wednesday for the newest episode of this Call of Cthulhu Actual Play original setting that places our investigators in Colonial North America shortly after ratification.

Themes and warnings: This intro includes mystery, occult imagery, tension, and heavy themes. Listener discretion is advised.

About this season: The Palimpsest Society is a Call of Cthulhu actual play podcast set in 1784 Philadelphia, following a group of new initiates as they uncover the hidden costs of knowledge, power, and transformation.

Follow the show: Find The Palimpsest Society on social media and wherever you listen to podcasts @thepalimpsestsociety

The Show Begins:

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Alright, everyone, welcome to the very first Palim Cess Society Sanity Check, which is going to be our talk back episode that we do in between scenarios to give everyone a chance to reflect on where their character’s been, to talk about things that happened in gameplay, to digest a few of the themes that we’ve maybe introduced along the way. I am your co-host Ryan McLaughlin, the keeper of Arcane Lore here on our Call of Cthulhu Actual Play podcast. And with me today, as always, is just the best crew of TTRPG players that I’ve ever had the chance to roll dice with. And they are.

Ezra Merrick

My name is Seth Dellinger and I play Ezra Merritt.

Dr. Prudence

Hey, hey, hey, I am Alicia Filiolo and I am playing Dr. Prudence Abercrombie.

Erin

Hi, I’m Erin Hippel and I’m playing Merit Vale.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

What’s going on, guys? My name is Michael Linsey, and I’m Captain

Ezra Merrick

Ha ha

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Edmund Ashcroft.

Erin

That was giving big nineties was up vibes. Wow.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Right.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Yeah, yeah. We’re keeping it d I’m slowly going insane,

Ezra Merrick

I feel like I undersold myself now.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

so I had to I I had to throw it out there.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: We’re we’re like in a nineties Budweiser Super Bowl halftime commercial now. I love it. I love it. Don’t tone it

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Yeah. I’m giving my best YouTuber.

Dr. Prudence

my god. I thought we were gonna go into like you’re listening to

Ezra Merrick

Yes.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: down at all as we’re hanging out tonight. so friends, we got a couple of things on the agenda. F the first thing on the agenda is Getting your characters skilled up a little bit, which you have all done prior to coming here tonight. But to let the listeners who might be new to Call of Cthulhu know, basically any of the skill roles that you did along the way, which you were able to succeed on without using luck points, you checked off. And then after the scenario was successfully completed, you had the opportunity to roll against that skill again, but this time hoping to go over the skill. So for instance, if you had a skill that was at a 50 and you succeeded on that at some point in the scenario by rolling a 40, you got to check that off. But now, after the scenario, you’re hoping to roll 51 or above. For any of those skills that you had that successful, unsuccessful rolling above role, you got to add one D10 to that skill. So I would love to hear from you all what skills you increased, and maybe how you think your character is internalizing that or will be processing that as we start into the next scenario. Who wants to jump in?

Ezra Merrick

Yeah, I can do I can I can hop in first.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah, go for it, Seth.

Ezra Merrick

well, I believe my only skill that I actually succeeded in was like very very early in the beginning of the of the first of our first session was my spot hidden. my current skill then was a sixty. Did my roll, I got seventy-nine, so I rolled higher.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yes.

Ezra Merrick

I rolled my D ten and I got a four. So now my skills at sixty-four. And I think this, you know, it’s not like it’s about middle of the board. So I think with everything that my character has been going through, you know, it it does weigh on there. You know, I I did spot, you know, a lot of things not the typical person would.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Sure.

Ezra Merrick

But just coupled with all the fear and all the sanity loss that Ezra was experiencing, I can see how it’s about middle of the

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah, that makes perfect sense. And we should say too that having just that one skill to go up in is not at all uncommon. Call of Cthulhu is a game where skill progression can be pretty slow. I really particularly like the skills-based progression. I was sharing with a few of you all off-air because to me it makes more narrative sense in game. You know, some games have always bothered me where you’ve got, well, hey gang, great news. last night I learned three new spells. wow. How’d how’d you do that? Well, I went from level four to level five. Okay, I mean that might make for fun gameplay, but it doesn’t make a whole lot of narrative. sense. Whereas here we’ve got right, right.

Ezra Merrick

There’s no substance to it, right? Yeah.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Whereas with this skills-based progression system that Kalakthulu employs, it makes a lot of sense to me that Ezra’s getting better at spotting hidden things because in the narrative of the story, he’s been having to spot things that were hidden. He’s practicing the skill. So I Personally find that and you know I work as an educator for my day job, and to me that makes a great deal of pedagogical sense too, right? How do we get better at things? We practice,

Ezra Merrick

Right, right. You do it.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: but it’s not easy and having that one skill go up, you know, not bad for a short scenario to start off the campaign with, Ezra.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

And if I may interject, like I think it’s interesting

Ezra Merrick

Why, thank you. Do it.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Please do.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

as you do get better at the skill, you it’s easier to baseline succeed in those skills, but then you know, if you have a if you’re trying to roll above a ninety in this case,

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Mm-hmm.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

it’s it’s often more and more difficult as you are getting better at that skill to increase your

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Absolutely.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

level. You know, it’s difficult for a master swordsmith to become the greatest swordsmith in the history of the world because

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Right.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

even though he might be making little, you know, practicing and and making little strides, he’s he’s gotta to to reach that next mark is just much more difficult.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: That’s really well said, Mike. I think that going from someone who’s just a pure novice to someone who’s like, okay, you know, that’s that’s easy. So if you’re trying to get that skill up from a 25 to a 35, that’s gonna be exponentially easier than going from a 75 to an 85, right? And that makes sense to the real world, and I think it makes a whole lot of narrative sense within the world of Call of Cthulhu for sure. Michael, do you want to go ahead and tell us how Captain Ashcroft is doing on his skills?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

yeah, so he learned a a new skill during this by reading an ancient arcane book about non-Euclidean

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Mm-hmm.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

navigation. And because we’ve been diving through the well and

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Mm-hmm.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

more up and north and wester than west and all of these things, I’ve

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Mm-hmm.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

gotten several attempts at it, so I did get to succeed one of those, and so I am getting slightly better at non Euclidean navigation. So that’s pretty good. that’s pretty much it for me. I I did I did succeed on a a medical check, but you said I have to succeed without using a luck point and I

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Right.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

and I had to use a luck point in order to do that. So so I will stay at my one for for my medicine checks from here on out.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: That’s all right. I did owe you all an explanation on the whole non-Euclidean thing. So a couple of things are going on with that.

Ezra Merrick

yeah.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: One is that that is a shout out to Call of Cthulhu, the original short story by H.P. Lovecraft, where he references non-Euclidean geometry. wanna read you all that passage from that famous story. Quote I mention his talk about angles because it suggests something Wilcox had told me of his awful dreams. He said that the geometry of the dream place he saw was abnormal, non-Euclidean, and loathsomely redolent of spheres and dimensions apart from ours. Parker slipped as the other three were plunging frenziedly over endless vistas of green crusted rocks to the boat, and Johansen swears he was swallowed up by an angle of masonry which shouldn’t have been there, an angle which was acute, but behaved as if it were obtuse. End quote. So

Ezra Merrick

Lovely.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I full confession, I love that passage and And part because as someone who majored in math in college, I’m here to tell you that non-Euclidean geometry is actually a thing. But a lot of times when I hear people talk about that passage from Lovecraft, I hear it spoken about as if Lovecraft made it up to be nonsense. now it would have been nonsense if I’m if I’m remembering my history of math correctly, in the 1780s. I I’m if I’m remembering correctly, non-Euclidean geometry kind of came onto the scene in the math world in the early eighteen hundreds. I might have to fact check myself and correct myself later on. But all of that to say, It’s real and it’s one of my favorite passages from the original Call of Cthulhu. And I also think it’s a great horror element to slip in. Like you’re in this place, you’re in this well that doesn’t even make sense geometrically to the way you’re used to perceiving the world at I think it’s an effective horror element in Lovecraft, and I hope it was an effective horror element in our game. So that is the explanation. Sweet. Thanks, man.

Ezra Merrick

It was.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I’ll go complimenting go compliment fishing more often with Seth. I Yeah, for sure, for sure. Just like your

Ezra Merrick

You gotta earn it. You gotta earn it.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: skill increases in Call of Cthulhu, right? So all that to say, that’s the explanation for the non-Euclidean navigation I owed you all. Who wants to share next about their character’s skill increases?

Dr. Prudence

Go. so Dr. Prudence Abercrombie, she had quite a few roles, and I had a success with medicine and I had a success with Spot Hidden. and so I rolled both of those. My spot hidden didn’t really get any better. There was no real growth there over the last experience, the last scenario, but with the medicine, Prudence. I did roll a a success with her. I mean, I failed it. I got a hundred. It’s always funny when you see three zeros show up on dice. And I’m like, is that like a one or a z a hundred? Like or a zero? Like, what is it?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Mm-hmm.

Dr. Prudence

and I ended up getting to increase that, which was great. and also a testament to who prudence is and how she I think would gain. additional knowledge or skill in that moment in this scenario. So I think that was fitting and I mean, I there wasn’t a lot of like I found a lot of things in the house. I saw things, I experienced things, but I do think that succeeding at the medicine role, for leveling up or increasing and learning was the best. I I really do, because she learned something in that moment. And I won’t spoil it for the rest of the talk back, but I think medicine is absolutely where it should have landed with the role.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: That’s great. Yeah, I think it makes perfect sense narratively with where Prudence has focused her time in the story so far and picking up the the tone that had that kind of arcane midwifery technique that she picked up there. and

Dr. Prudence

yeah, yeah.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: you know, sh she was immediately attentive to trying to figure out what happened to the folks that passed away that you discovered in the well. so I love that that skill increase jives so beautifully with the story.

Dr. Prudence

Yeah, same. It couldn’t have fallen better.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Awesome. Aaron, how’s Merritt doing skill wise?

Erin

Yeah, so I was actually so I was hunting up and down for the exact number, but I’m I’m trying to find the new character sheet, Ryan. I had it in a browser window

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Okay.

Erin

and all of my 100 emotional support tabs or whatever still remains to be seen. but Merritt,

Ezra Merrick

You too.

Erin

yeah, Merritt’s doing well. Increased increased their spot hidden, which is great given that in the tunnel they Much like Euclidean navigation were obtuse instead of acute, just running around in circles. But luckily that skill did increase. And I don’t wanna brag everyone, but Merritt got a little of their sanity increased as well. so Merritt’s coming

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah.

Erin

into this with a little bit more sanity than what they had when we all last left each other. So

Ezra Merrick

That’s right. You did you did award

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Let’s talk about that, yeah.

Ezra Merrick

us or or bestow upon us a a recovery to our sanity.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I did, yeah. So the call No. Sorry.

Erin

You mean it wasn’t just me, right I thought I was special. Right.

Ezra Merrick

sorry, yeah

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I I I do have my favorites that I play on this podcast, but I’m not going to reveal them through the sanity increase or decrease. no, just kidding. But with the sanity increase, the Call of Cthulhu keeper book does give keepers the right to give like a 1d6 sanity recovery after successfully completing a scenario. And I forget the exact wording of the book, but essentially it makes it clear that you have To have played well, right? Like you have to have survived in an honorable way and not through skullduggery or nastiness. And if that happens, then I can you know refuse to give you that 1d6 of sanity back. But you all were awesome, so you earned your 1d6 of sanity back. But yeah, Aaron, I think that if I remember correctly, Merritt’s sanity is maybe actually even a little higher than what they started with now. Is that right?

Erin

Yes, that is correct. And I believe it occurred because Merritt did not respond to the giant in the water with a boom boom.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Hmm Well, shots fired at Captain Ashcroft there.

Ezra Merrick

Ha ha

Erin

I’m teasing, but I mean that was amazing, right? use my gun

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Listen, shit

Erin

Ha ha ha.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

shit started happening. I’m a soldier, have

Ezra Merrick

And sometimes violence could be the answer in a narrative sense.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

A and indeed it was in the moment, and did not go in in Ashcroft’s favor, that’s for sure.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Sanity

Ezra Merrick

Now

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: recovery can also happen as a result of doing some self-care, shall we say, in between scenarios, which you all will have the opportunity to do when we resume the campaign next episode. So that is also a possibility. you all also, if I’m not mistaken, picked up a tiny little bit of Cthulhu Mythos skill.

Ezra Merrick

I was gonna I was gonna ask you about that. You you did mention that and I am completely ignorant on this. What what does that mean?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: No, that’s that’s okay. So each of the four tomes that you picked up in the little library and boom a house there has a slight increase of your Cthulhu Mythos score, which ordinarily starts at zero for most player characters. We can get in the exceptions later on in the campaign if it comes up, but you All I think either got 1% or 2% from your cursory readings of the Mythos tome. All of those tomes have an associated time to fully study them or how long it would take for you to really digest it all. I think there’s at least one of your tomes that’s 13 weeks, and another one is maybe 26 weeks, things like that. And should you spend that time over the next few weeks to really get to know those tomes, you might pick up additional spells. you would for sure pick up additional mythos percentage. However, there’s a cost-benefit analysis that goes into that because your max sanity does decrease by whatever your mythos skill is. So it’s 99 minus whatever your mythos skill is. So if you just picked up two percentage in your Cthulhu Mythos, for instance, your sanity will never go higher than 97 again. Which is just a subtle nod towards the the Lovecraftian conceit that the more you find out about the way the world really is, the less your puny human mind is able to really cope.

Ezra Merrick

Love it. Absolutely love it. Now is this the I have two numbers on mine. Those are like plus one slash plus three. The plus one is what we get now. And then you

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Right.

Ezra Merrick

said after that full round of studying we get that plus three or whatever that next number is. Cool.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Right, if you have spent time to really digest the material in game.

Ezra Merrick

Awesome.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Sweet. So let’s talk a little bit about this first scenario, which we have called the initiation. Give me your initial reactions. Give me your thoughts and experiences, especially from the perspective of, I know we’ve got a lot of folks on this cast who are newer to Call of Cthulhu as TTRPG. I would love to hear that perspective in particular, but just give me thoughts and initial reactions on how the story is going so far for you and for your character.

Dr. Prudence

I that was so funny. We’re all just kinda like looking at each other doing like the Spider Man thing like which Spider-Man, you, you, you. I love table play. I love

Ezra Merrick

You, you, you, you

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Right.

Dr. Prudence

I love this game and I love what Chaossium has created. And so I think this is coming from the co creator of the show. I I leave all of the story to Ryan and the bones of the Palimpsest Society is really all that I’ve had part of this story. And so I I come in not knowing anything except I knew what the Palamsa Society’s name was. I knew where we were. I knew the first decade we were starting. and or the first era I should say. And I built my character and I can’t wait for the world to to know prudence and pray to the gods above and below that she lives. But walking into session one, I was blown away with just the unraveling of the first word that came from Ryan’s mouth that I was hooked. And I say that as the person who’s also editing the show, but I listened to it over and over and over again. The first episode, and I’m still so hooked. And I as we moved through this scenario, I was just shocked that the bones of something with just a few mate words could create something so cool in Ryan’s mind that we get to be a part of. And just seeing how each of these four characters it made sense. And each character, it feels like we’re so beautifully. crafted within the space and I think that’s really what I love about playing a human and having a human experience because we are human and we get to be able to understand a little bit better about that human emotion. and so I just thought that it was it was really good. I was really shocked and I mean we’re only a few episodes in and Prudence is just so well suited, especially for this last scenario. So I think for the first the first moments I was just in awe.

Ezra Merrick

Love it. If I can like piggyback off that, before our session zero and even in our session zero, none of us had really told each other what kind of character we wanted to play and both mechanically and narratively. you know, this Ezra Merrick has been a character I’ve been wanting to play for years and he’s always been in my in my back pocket, in the back of my mind, which in turn makes him a part of me. Like every character that I do play and to see the dynamic between the four of us if we and the keeper as well and how the how all of us play off of each other narratively, it’s beautiful.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I wanna just say, you know, in terms of the creative process, that none of this is happening without Alicia. Because Alicia, I don’t remember the exact details of the conversation we had when we were talking about ideas for an actual play podcast, but the entire name Palumces Society came from you, buddy. you I I forget exactly how you worded it, but you were talking about hanging out in Colonial Williamsburg and And learning about how they made palum cests. And I, to be honest with you, was like, what in the fuck is a palum zest? And then I Googled it. I was

Ezra Merrick

Me too. Me too.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: like, yeah, yeah, yeah. Let’s be transparent. We all had to Google palum cest.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Seems very non Euclidean.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: yes, right, right. So

Ezra Merrick

Ooh.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I immediately was like Wow, okay, what a cool word. I agree, it’s like the best word ever, but also what a great metaphor for what we try to do with American history. But also what a great metaphor for the opportunity there is when you’re playing a tabletop role-playing game. I think that we take these old books, these old stories, and we try to write our own words on top of them, right? And that’s true whether you’re playing a published TTRPG campaign, something that someone else has written. You’re you’re writing your own words over top of that. I think any GM will tell you that that’s the experience, right? and I think it’s true when you are writing your own homebrew stuff as we are in this campaign, because you’re taking in Inspiration from these different things, whether it’s from history or from Lovecraft or from the Call Cthulhu material that Chaossium’s put out over the last four and a half decades. Like you’re writing your own words over what’s already been written. And so I think it’s just a really fun and interesting metaphor for TTRPG play in general. But also, I’m really excited for the campaign to continue because I I hope and I suspect that. that the true nature of the Palum Cess Society will slowly reveal itself over the course of our campaign and give us more to chew on in that regard and in regards to that word.

Dr. Prudence

I think it’s really important, sorry, Erin, I don’t mean to cut you off. I think it’s really important to note too that in Colonial Williamsburg, it is the only place in the country where this this couple miles live in the 17 s like sixties. And the the book binding shop is like it’s I think it’s called the printing office or the printing shop, but historically it has ran as the print shop for Williamsburg. It was a book bindery, it was the post office. It was a bookstore all in the eighteenth century, so 1700s. And they do a beautiful job of showcasing what a palimcest is and the importance of paper and part or of parchment, right? And the making of that. And it was made to withstand time and time and time and story and story and story. And so I just I think it’s really important for people to know that you can see that in its historical. context and being made today in Colonial Williamsburg. And it’s life-changing to see that stories are told over and over and over again and our human existence is continuously told by story and we connect through story. And I’m so glad that we chose and stuck with the Palamsa Society and that I get to be part of those layered stories with the five of you.

Erin

I’m delighted by that. And it’s also why I believe we can market this as a history education podcast. I’m sure that would fly, right? but yeah, but

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Why not?

Erin

I love that. Something I also I’m

Ezra Merrick

Sure.

Erin

I’m appreciating the I’m appreciating the surprises that come along when you allow for the alchemy of a bunch of characters to come together. And I actually, Michael, I don’t want to put you on the spot, but you said something really beautiful. that we didn’t capture on the recording about your character and how you were thinking about coming into the group dynamic and how some things shifted and it just it felt too good to lose to, you know, the non recording world. And I’m just wondering if you might be willing to talk a little bit about that because I found that really meaningful.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

yeah, yeah. I I was saying that, you know, like a lot of times with many of many of my characters, I will Do the backstory, I’ll create this character that I see, and I see him very vividly, right? This is how he’s gonna speak. This is exactly what he’s going to think about when he runs into these obstacles and when something confronts him in a way. And immediately, as soon as I opened my mouth, that all went out the window. You know, the the backstory work was there, but interacting and speaking from his perspective, he became for example, like I saw him as like a you know, he’s he’s a British officer. He’s gonna see all of these colonial people as like less than him. And I think there is still that color there, right? But he’s also been a prisoner for a very long time. he doesn’t he’s he’s walking on eggshells because he doesn’t know why he’s been released. these people seem to be, you know Gracious to him. They’re not they’re not giving any animosity. So with his his upbringing kind of bubbling back up to the surface, he’s like, Okay, well, I’ll maintain decorum with these people. They’re maintaining it with me. And now he’s more instead of like this gruff, like, I’ll I’ll work with these people because I have to, it’s more of like, He he’s constantly on his to toes. He’s a little more neurotic. and yeah, I I think what happened was that I built the shape of a character, and then as I started speaking with them, the colors started flowing to the canvas, and now he is much more I think a a truly a more interesting character. and that’s what happens when you have expectations, right? You should just lower your expectations, everybody. I mean generally

Ezra Merrick

Absolutely. Absolutely.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

like that’s a joke, but seriously, like y the the lower your expectations, the more you can be open to something that you are faced with that is unexpected.

Ezra Merrick

I’ll I’ll reveal that in the the few hours before our first session I was online researching what a seventeen eighty four Pennsylvanian accent would sound like for hours. And then as soon as we hit go, it went completely out the window and then I thought, I’m not gonna force it, I’m just gonna be me. And it’s it’s defined who Ezra is now in my mind.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Now, granted, I understand I have the greatest British accent anyone’s ever heard. And it’s never shifting and swaying into different

Ezra Merrick

Truly. World class.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

types in it by any means. So I understand

Ezra Merrick

Ha ha ha.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

why you may have felt a little a little nervous, but let me reassure you, as the greatest voice actor to have ever lived, I’m sure it would have been wonderful.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Really it’s your it’s your humility that does it for me, Michael.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Ha ha ha ha.

Dr. Prudence

I think coming in with that like first

Ezra Merrick

So humble.

Dr. Prudence

statement of like you yank, I was like, wow. I

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Yeah.

Dr. Prudence

didn’t know where Captain Edmund Ashcroft was going. I I didn’t expect I didn’t know if I expected him to be British and a p a prisoner of the revolution, or if he was British and was on the the colonist side. So I wasn’t sure and then I was all, wow. Okay, he absolutely was put in there by Hamilton or Burr. Just totally.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Yeah. And honestly, that was the moment that I think everything shifted. You can see that he’s like he’s forcing it and and didn’t get the reaction. And so instantly I I Michael and the character both pulled back at the same time. but I you know, going back, I I know I appreciate you giving me the floor, Aaron, but like your your character is definitely someone who he is would not connect with prior to this moment and he is very invested in Vale. I and I’m not sure why personally, but there’s something about Vail that he is like deeply empathetic and sympathetic. And I and I just I can’t understand it and I’m just gonna go with it. So I’m really excited to see how that relationship blossoms.

Erin

Perhaps it is the aggressive awkwardness. Just aggressive, aggressively awkward.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Yeah. Yeah. Just

Ezra Merrick

It’s too real. We got too real.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah.

Dr. Prudence

That’s that’s so good.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

it’s so good, dude.

Erin

Yeah, the moment the moment with the two of them at the table, I was touched by that. Like I wasn’t expecting that when your character came over and seemed to give a single shit about what was happening there. And there was just this like, you know, as a highly educated man that you came over to, you know, pay attention to the distress that was starting to happen there touched me in a way that I think I was surprised by in the moment.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Same definitely goes for me. That was a beautiful moment that I’m really excited about.

Dr. Prudence

I that’s the beauty of role play. I think that we talk about improvisation, we talk about all these different stage acting and method acting. And I think there’s something really beautiful about five people coming together around a table and telling the story completely from improv. The only thing that is not improvised is the role of the die. And that is literally fate. And I think it’s really cool that. we can come together and we all have maybe a five sub five a sub five hundred word backstory and To create these deep connections or what we will hope to be deep connections is truly remarkable. And I don’t think it can I don’t think it can be scripted, right? And I think that there’s something very beautiful about this way of storytelling that is just so raw and real and really pushes you beyond the limits.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: That’s really well said. Just this week, I was listening to a an episode of another podcast that I really, really love called Weird Studies. Shout out to the Weird Studies guys. the title of the episode is Artworks Are People Too. And without getting too much into their material, because it’s really, really good, and I highly recommend it if you’re interested. When you’re creating something, they argue, you put something of your own personhood into that thing. And that’s true of Yeah, and you’re Yeah, and

Ezra Merrick

Absolutely. Absolutely.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: that’s true of whether you are creating a painting or a piece of music or you’re writing a story, or if you’re playing a TTRPG and creating a character or creating a world for those characters to to exist in. I love, and you talked about this earlier, Seth, I love that you feel like Ezra, you know, there’s there’s a a blurry area of overlap where it’s like where does Ezra end and Seth begin and vice versa, right?

Ezra Merrick

Yeah, absolutely.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: It it’s a powerful experience, I think, for, you know, folks that maybe haven’t experienced that in other creative outlets to kind of see that come alive in TTRPG characters and TTRPG worlds. I would love to ask what your experiences of the well and of her were like.

Erin

Okay, let me just start by saying

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Please do.

Erin

when that fucking candle

Ezra Merrick

Yeah.

Erin

showed up again, I was like, boy, we’ve done everything we possibly can not to sit at the table that Ryan has literally sat for us, set up with the

Ezra Merrick

Ha ha.

Erin

can. Like it was very obvious where we were supposed to go. So when we went down there and we looked in the well

Dr. Prudence

Yeah.

Erin

and there was another candle, I was like, As above, so below, everyone, I think we need to go. Like, I think we can’t just kind of pussyfoot around the situation anymore. and so I yeah, I I listen, I was like,

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Not above railroading my players when it needs to happen.

Ezra Merrick

Ha ha ha ha.

Erin

there’s gonna come a point where every time we look, we’re gonna hear Ryan say then there was a candle. It’s like we need to go to the candle,

Dr. Prudence

my god.

Erin

everyone. This will be a six-episode arc

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Walk this way. Yes.

Erin

just to get to the fucking table. Yes, walk this way.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah.

Erin

So

Dr. Prudence

god.

Ezra Merrick

Now now Seth knew about the candle.

Erin

I I think and by the way, I think we chose violence when we chose the one down the well. I’m just saying that it might have been fewer dead bodies if we had just sat down at the table, but maybe not. I don’t know. We’ll never know. good. Your shaking head tells me there would have

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: No

Erin

been dead bodies either way. Okay.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah, no the the table, you know, you you there’s time for the table.

Dr. Prudence

There’s time for the table.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: The well was the well was where you were supposed to go.

Ezra Merrick

What a line.

Dr. Prudence

There’s time for the table. I think the well, the I love it. Look at the math teacher mathing.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Times table, if you will, mathematically speaking.

Dr. Prudence

I don’t like math. I’m a therapist for a reason. the the the

Ezra Merrick

The engineer loves it, thank you.

Dr. Prudence

well is a moment where prudence I think the moment when Vale and Prudence get pushed aside so Ezra can bolt the building. was a moment where I, Alicia, thought, is this like splitting the party in another TTRPG? Like, are we supposed to be doing this? And then we kind of just looked at each other and then went down. I was really concerned because we left on a cliffhanger of, you know, Seth is looking or Ezra is looking at this well. And when we came back, I was very concerned about the whale. And I think there’s a moment where we see prudence getting like hyper fixated on there’s a candle in the water. There’s a candle in the water. And some people know that like I have a stutter, but that wasn’t my stutter. That was truly this moment of of prudence getting stuck in this this moment.

Erin

You know, Alicia, it’s almost as though she lived her life like a candle in the well.

Dr. Prudence

Can that please be our merch? You know, like

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Mm.

Ezra Merrick

Ha ha ha.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: We’re gonna have to consult an IP lawyer on that first.

Dr. Prudence

I think she, you know. I think we changed it 20%. But you know what? I do think that Sir E Sir EJ, I think would be like, yes, yes, that candle was in the well. but that well moment was interesting because we go down. I won’t speak for anybody else, but. Prudence gets in, you know, like there’s some like flubbin’ fallen, and there are these bodies, and as she scurries up, instantly she is in work mode. And Dr. Prudence Abercrombie is this remarkable person, and she just knows right away, gotta roll my sleeves up. And as she’s checking these bodies and learning that this doesn’t look national, there’s this concern that washed over me. And when we start hearing the Alicia got chills and Prudence knew exactly what was happening. And in that moment, that’s when I knew that Ryan had taken the bones of the Palum Cest Society and created something truly remarkable because the story was complete before Ryan got my character sheet. And Prudence was Prudence has been built for this and made for this, and her entire life is all about. Bringing children into Colonial Williamsburg and and and helping mothers give birth. And that moment for prudence was heartbreaking and concerned because how long had she been waiting? And how long had nobody noticed what was actually going on? And if they would have stopped and asked or stopped and just given a moment, could she have been freed? From whatever this has been eons ago or months ago or years ago. Like I prudence just didn’t know. And that’s really a lot about Prudence’s self-care right now, is just trying to process through what that means. And I think the well for Alicia was very Mut it was very I don’t wanna say it’s not maternal, but felt very welcoming but very heavy, like the well was welcoming, but maybe that welcome was scary. Like I don’t know, is that how Prudence is gonna be experiencing all these very weird things she just witnessed? Does it feel welcoming? She’s kind of in this weird spot.

Erin

And I have to say a couple things that strike me here. Well, first of all, I think that Sir EJ, as you call him, would approve this simply because of how you described what prudence wears. Because I feel as though that is something he would absolutely be like, yes, I would also too wear that, first of all. But also

Dr. Prudence

Yes.

Erin

s something that creeps me out, and you, Alicia, don’t know this yet, but Ryan does. Because why my character also, though it did not come up in the moment. recognized the breathing because my character comes from some pretty important stuff as it relates to midwifery. And I’m gonna leave it there. But that

Dr. Prudence

No

Erin

was all yeah, that was all built into the backstory before I ever talked with any of you. So I was very creeped out and I was like, no, this can’t be happening now. and it in fact was not, but that’s all I’ll say. And I’m gonna

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

That’s so crazy guys because Captain Edmund Ashcroft

Ezra Merrick

That it is.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

is also a midwife. Did I tell you guys this? Yeah. Yeah, yeah. How crazy.

Ezra Merrick

And I was also born from a mother, so

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I I do just want to say that that is absolutely

Erin

How did this happen?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: the case that I was sitting in my favorite tea shop, shout out Kalijah T in Tampa, Florida, finishing up my notes on this scenario when I received Alicia’s character sheet. And I think a short time later, Aaron’s character sheet and reading through the backstories did absolutely make me go, my God, are you kidding me? The synchronicity is just too. Fucking good.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

That’s fabulous.

Ezra Merrick

And it and it’s it’s wild how this

Dr. Prudence

This is insane.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

I love that.

Ezra Merrick

is coincidental now be because Edmund Ashcroft and Ezra Merrick also unknowingly share a similar background in their military histories. Yeah.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: There you go. There you go.

Dr. Prudence

Y’all, we don’t live anywhere near each other. I think I live

Ezra Merrick

Not at all.

Dr. Prudence

closest to Aaron. And so like this is this is wild. Woo!

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I love all of that.

Ezra Merrick

Yeah, we’re we’re literally all over the country.

Dr. Prudence

So I wanna know though, from the the guys, what does what does the well I mean, there’s a moment with Edmund where

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Yeah, no hold on. W screw Edmund for a second. Ez Ezra is literally like constantly being pulled through trauma down here. And I I have to like plea please, like every time you’re like,

Ezra Merrick

Yeah, yeah.

Dr. Prudence

Fair.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Hey, can I roll to see at this? And you failed, and then it’s just like my mind is blown. And

Ezra Merrick

Yeah. Yep.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

then you’re What what if it’s this? You failed. Okay, my mind’s even more blown. So please, please discuss.

Dr. Prudence

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Ezra Merrick

for for Ezra, definitely you know, you you you mentioned that we split the party, quote unquote. And it it was due to Ezra’s frustrations of what really drew him to Boma House in the first place. and in in his searching of that, not finding it, it’s like fine, I I’ll figure this out some other way and I’m gonna leave. And then Ryan as you being the the the narrator of of herding of the cats, so to speak, you’re like, no, this this way will give you the answers that you want. Essentially, but in a more narrative tone. and then I take the reins from that and play out a scene and now I’m thinking, Seth is thinking now, how do I incorporate everybody else into this? Because this is a collaborative game. How can I flavor this in such a way tw that makes sense? So Ezra got immensely scared, started losing the sanity, started seeking people to help him, which the other characters absolutely did. And it’s still doing.

Dr. Prudence

Does that give the good captain anything he wants to add? Does does Michael have anything to add to that?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Y yeah, so so okay, so I’ll say this. me, Michael playing Edmund, like it there was like the the first section in the house was very slow. I I was like we’re all getting to know each other as players, and then, you know, I think w It felt like this is what I kept thinking of while we were playing. In this house, it felt like if you guys have ever seen the movie Cabin in the Woods and they’re all down in the basement and the people are watching and they’re like, what will they choose? Are they gonna choose the book that will send the zombies? Are they gonna choose the thing that op unleashes the vampires? It’s like that’s what it felt like. It felt like Ryan was just waiting for us to like reach out our hand and touch something we should not touch and then all hell breaks loose. And I was just kind of waiting for that. And it’s you know, I I was like, is it the upstairs? Is it the table? Okay, something hasn’t happened yet. Okay, it might be the books. Someone pulls a book down and they they get this knowledge and whatnot. And as soon as the well was introduced, I knew. This was it, right? This this is our our journey. And as sil as soon as the well was introduced to Edmund, this whole time he’s tiptoeing around the house, n n uncomfortable. He doesn’t want to be rude, he doesn’t want to be y he’s n unsure of why he is supposed to be here. And the well represented like as a hole in the ground, there’s only one way to go. And that that represented the d the direction he was looking for. Right? The light at the end of the tunnel. Yeah, yeah. The yeah. I well I said down

Ezra Merrick

One and a half ways to go, right? Yeah.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: One one point seven, I think, actually.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

you know, not south. but yes, it’s

Ezra Merrick

Ha ha ha.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

that that that light was his i his guiding light essentially. It was like finally it was also, you know, facing a darkness, a danger, protecting someone who is afraid is something dear to him, and we will continue to find out why. but seeing like a very shaken comrade, so to speak. he was like, I’ll I’ll lead the way and that’s why he rolled up his his pant legs and he was like, I’ll be the first one down. I’m leading the charge here. and so yeah, that’s that’s kind of what the well really inspired in Edmund and myself.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I love that. That’s really well said.

Dr. Prudence

How is the well for you, Erin?

Erin

Well, I think probably what stands out to me the most and I yeah, I was actually rethinking how Merritt experienced some of the moments before and the way they were thinking about symmetry because Merritt is somebody who what what drives them To a point of concern is not fear, it’s a lack of explanation. It’s like a lack of they’re very unnerved by things that don’t have a categorization, like have a way for them to fit them into a pattern that makes sense. And so I think, Of what motivated them to move down into the well was this is it’s obvious that a person did this, and that was very comforting to them. Like there’s a ladder here, a person did this. whatever’s happening here is happening down there, and certainly there’s gonna be an explanation once we get there. And something I was also thinking about, which is slightly adjacent to the well, because I gave you I gave you a little rib about using the gun on that particular creature. But just as I was listening to you describe Captain Edmund Ashcroft, and by the way, whenever I hear Prudence Abercrombie, I want to sing the Abercrombie and Fitch song from the 90s. It’s like a 90s night. Anyway, appreciating how actually I I joked about that, but that was the perfect response to someone who is responding based on the way that they know to deal with a problem and a situation. Like it kind of creates this brilliant moment of like, this is what I have. and so, you know, thinking about that from Merritt’s perspective once we were down there, who has like tracking and knowledge related to understanding the echolocation and how we were all kind of doing the best with what we had. And again, I was just I was very moved by how quickly it felt like we all moved together when that didn’t have to be the choice. That we all made. You know, like there were those moments where Ezra was like, I’m out of here. Fuck all of y’all, you know? And then,

Ezra Merrick

Yep.

Erin

and then we still, by Ryan’s brilliant manipulation, found our way to a candle in the well. And I was just, yeah,

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Okay.

Erin

I was appreciative of the fact that like I felt compelled and Merritt felt compelled to be like, yeah, we gotta go. So yeah.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Moths to the flame.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I love that. I love that. The well for me, you know, there’s a there’s a few things that went into the design of the well and into the design I put into her, because she is an original monster, I guess. I don’t like using the word monster when I’m talking about her, but I’ll get to that in a second. The Well is obviously just a classic spooky trope on some level, right? if you’re my age, the scariest movie you probably saw in high school was The Ring. And so, you know, there’s obviously layers there of my own experiences with horror.

Ezra Merrick

I was gonna say the descent, but same same idea, yeah.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Okay, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. But there’s also, you know, the aspect of so many initiation rites that involves a catabasis myth of some kind. Where it’s a myth of descent into an underworld. And that’s true of initiation rights in so many cultures and so many places. And so if I was going to initiate your player characters into the Palimpsest Society, I did feel like some kind of catabatic move into a descent into an underworld was kind of necessary. But it linked up really well. Huh, see what I did there. Linked up well. with the whole concept that I had for her. Because as I think that you probably picked up on through the clues from like Genesis 16, 7, she’s very much inspired by the Hagar story in Genesis. And so In my mind, she’s not Hagar herself, but she might be something of an egregor of Hagar’s pain that has accumulated the pain and the righteous indignation of women in similar positions throughout the eons. And that was kind of what I was trying to represent with the patchwork skin. But she came to my mind as I was studying a womanist theologian by the name of Dolores Williams. And womanism is a theological movement that tries to explore the intersectionality between black liberation theology on the one hand and feminist theology on the other hand. And Dolores Williams has this fascinating look into Hagar. And if you haven’t read Genesis in a while. Basically, she is a slave woman from Egypt who is in Abraham’s household and In the narrative, God has promised a son, has promised an heir to Abraham and to Sarah. And Sarah comes along and says, Well, you know, I’m already 80, you’re probably not gonna have any kids with me. You should have a kid with my servant, as it’s euphemistically called in many of our modern English translations, Hagar. And so they do, and Abraham names the child Ishmael. There’s this whole big long thing where Sarah gets jealous of Hagar and Ishmael and kicks them out of the house. They escape to the desert where the angel of the Lord finds them by that well in Genesis 16:7. And Dolores Williams, this brilliant womanist theologian I mentioned earlier, really does this incredible job of interrogating that story and saying, hey, listen, this is the founding story of three faiths. And at the heart of this founding story, of three faiths, is the rape of an African woman. Whoa, holy shit, right? Holy shit. The founding myth, the founding story of three of the world’s major religions contains this story of the rape of a woman from Africa. And there’s this connection in my mind with Interrogating the story of the founding of America, too, where we know that part of the founding of America involves the rape of women from Africa, including Thomas Jefferson, you know, the author of our Declaration of Independence. So there’s this this overlap there in my mind between the themes that Hagar evokes and the themes that are evoked in the 1780s set in Philadelphia, where we were going, well. all of this. And so I wanted to take this egregore, her, as I’m calling her, and I wanted to find a way to represent her in a way that was gonna scare the shit out of you guys as players, but also honor her and so you know I put the crown of thorns around her I I didn’t give her eyes because I was trying to go for like a justice is blind kind of thing. I

Ezra Merrick

Yeah, that got me.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: sweet. I I gave her the bow and the arrows because there’s a reference in Genesis to Ishmael growing up to being a mighty hunter skilled with the bow, I believe is the reference. And it does not say that about Abraham or Isaac. And so I thought I must have got it from Mama, right? So that was the intent with her and to initiate you guys into that Palimpsest society story, I thought we gotta initiate them into the accumulated pain. Of so many women and under patriarchy for so long that it’s part of this founding story in the Bible. It was part of our founding story as a country, too. But I also wanted to initiate you guys into the hope that something different could happen, right? The story has been written, but it doesn’t mean that it can’t be written over. And so I loved when Dr. P walked in

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

But

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: and knew immediately that it was time to give Birth to something new and something hopeful. Yeah, go ahead.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

And what may I, I just wanted to say w I I I I one hundred percent agree and find that I what a beautiful moment that like the the macho man is running f headfirst into danger firing a gun, while Dr. Prudence brave and like emotionally like a a brick wall stands and like takes takes that pain in an emotional level, in just a better way, right? Like coming from someone who does a lot of fantasy T T RPGs, it’s like kill the monster, kill the monster. And

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

and my character still represents that in some way. Go, kill the monster, you know, defeat the enemy. And Dr. Prudence just a a a magnificent moment with the with the creature speaking to it them

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

her and yeah I just it it was a beautiful moment and I think the dichotomy of of you and I standing side by side was great. It was very memorable for me as a player and I think very memorable for Captain Ashcroft.

Erin

Yeah, and it has me thinking about how as someone who in my life as a person, as a human person, you will find me standing in solidarity with maligned individuals who’ve been maligned, whether human or more than human. don’t get me started on how Linnaeus hated amphibians and reptiles. It’s I won’t I won’t go down that rabbit hole. Something that I appreciated, it’s having me think of another. video game franchise who whose name I won’t mention because I don’t know if we’re allowed, where you are moving through a society that has come across a time of cultural darkness, and your initial goal is to kill these entities that you later find out are basically old gods. And One of the things that makes this particular game so compelling is that there comes a point in the narrative where you ask yourself, am I actually the good guy? Like am I actually who I think I am? And the importance of being willing to reflect on that feels like it showed up in this narrative and of course, you know, Ryan, one of the reasons I was hooked on your GMing was because of another campaign that you ran that I was in where you took another system’s monster and changed the story so that that monster had a motive that was very understandable. and in order to move forward, it wasn’t about burning something down. It was about building s building a relationship and being in right relationship was which is another thing I believe that womanism and black feminism speaks to directly about what it means to be in right relationship and not to be right. And so I really appreciated this

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yes.

Erin

narrative for that reason too.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I’m really grateful for that. I can’t promise that all of the monsters you face in this campaign will have good motives or have things that you’ll be empathetic with. Some of them are just gonna be fucking evil. Which ones are which will be part of your job to sort out, right? But I am

Ezra Merrick

yeah.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I am really looking forward to continuing on in this story with you all and continuing to slowly unveil. What’s in store for the Palumcess Society? And I hope that all of you listeners at home have enjoyed our conversation here. And I hope that if you’ve not already done so, that you will follow us at the Palumces Society on Instagram, and that you will subscribe to this podcast wherever you get your podcasts. And that you’ll join us again next time as we pick the story back up. Thanks everybody and have a great day.