Show Transcript and Show Notes for The Palimpsest Society a Bi-Weekly Call of Cthulhu Actual Play Podcast!

EP 2 Initiation: Candle in the Well

In this episode, we delve into the mysterious depths of the Palim Cess Society’s cave, where ancient symbols, strange water-filled chambers, and non-Euclidean architecture challenge the perceptions of our explorers. Join us as we explore biblical references, arcane symbols, and the unsettling discovery of four seemingly drowned bodies. Why does the water contain a candle from the second floor window, and what do the cryptic inscriptions reveal about the houseโ€™s dark history? Tune in to uncover the bizarre, the mystical, and the cosmic horror lurking beneath the surface.

Connect with the Crew on Instagram:

  • Ryan McLaughlin (Keeper) โ€“ย @thepalimpsestsociety
  • Erin Hippel (Merritt Vale) โ€“ย  @thepalimpsestsociety
  • Michael Hall Lindsay (Captain Ashcroft) โ€“ย @warsonggames
  • Alicia Figliuolo (Dr. Prudence Abercombie) โ€“ย @aliciafigliuolo
  • Seth Dellinger (Ezra Merrick) โ€“ @sethdellingervo

Welcome to The Palimpsest Society

Join us every other Wednesday for the newest episode of this Call of Cthulhu Actual Play original setting that places our investigators in Colonial North America shortly after ratification.

Themes and warnings: This intro includes mystery, occult imagery, tension, and heavy themes. Listener discretion is advised.

About this season: The Palimpsest Society is a Call of Cthulhu actual play podcast set in 1784 Philadelphia, following a group of new initiates as they uncover the hidden costs of knowledge, power, and transformation.

Follow the show: Find The Palimpsest Society on social media and wherever you listen to podcasts @thepalimpsestsociety

The Show Begins:

Initiation: Candle in the Well Ep 2

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Sometimes when I’m feeling powerless, I start to wonder, is there really any such thing as free will? I mean, we all make choices, no question about it. Sometimes they’re difficult choices even, where there isn’t one option that’s more obvious than the other. When you find yourself at the end of a long sequence of choices, don’t you sometimes begin to wonder if where you find yourself wasn’t always the inevitable destination? Did your choice even matter, or were you always going to wind up there? Still, though, you have to at least pretend like you have free will, right? There’s not really any other way to live a life. I mean you can agree with Nietzsche all you want about a morfati, but you still have to at least choose to love your fate. At least that’s what I do. And you do too, don’t you, dear listener? Love your fate, that is. I mean you chose to download this episode. You chose to push play. You had chose To adjust the volume just now, when I started talking to make sure that was just right for comfortable listening. So you’ll at least try to love fate for bringing you here to Burma House, where Ezra, led by his own series of inevitable choices, now stands next to a well, peering over the side and seeing a rope ladder going down, down, down. Because this is the second episode of the Palim Cess Society, a Call of Cthulhu actual play podcast set in these here United States. And I’m your keeper of Arcane Lore and co-host, Ryan McLaughlin. Alongside me here are my illustrious colleagues that I’ll invite now to reintroduce themselves to you.

Merritt Vale

Hi, my name’s Erin Hippel. My pronouns are they, them, theirs, and I’ll be playing Merit Vail, whose pronouns depend on who is asking.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Hi, I’m Michael Hall Lindsay, and I am he him, and I’ll be playing Captain Edmund Ashcroft.

Dr. Prudence

Hello, I’m Alicia Filiolo, she her playing Doctor Prudence Abercrombie.

Ezra Merrick

And hello, I’m Seth Dellinger, and I’m playing Ezra Merrick.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Thanks everybody. Before we get back into things, let me give you a little bit of a recap of where things stood at the end of our last episode. When we last left our four initiates, they had just begun to feel that grew for themselves. A house that Philadelphia forgets to notice, a candle that burns for no one, four letters, four strange and terrible little tokens, and a summons signed by regents who call themselves. The Palimces Society. With an odd motto, Saway et Coagula, those who dissolve and those who coagulate. Now Merritt Vale found a name at last for the thing that they had carried in silence for three years. Dr. Prudence Abercrombie found a book that taught her something she never asked to know. Captain Edmund Ashcroft found his careful manners fraying at the edges of a room that wanted nothing from him but his attention. And Ezra Merrick, our reluctant medium, a man who has made a fine living out of not believing in any of this, found himself alone in a courtyard, staring down into that well, watching a rope ladder disappear into the dark and Feeling quite certain that something down there was staring back, maybe? Feeling back? Who’s to say? I don’t think the Burma House is quite finished with our friends. and the letter they received did promise initiation. But it didn’t promise that initiation would be gentle. So let’s all light a candle. Just the one, mind you, no others. And let us see what weights at the bottom of that well. This is the Palim Cess Society, and let’s get back to the story.

Dr. Prudence

Snap, let’s go.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: So Ezra, I do believe that we left off

Ezra Merrick

boy. Yes.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: not just with you staring down into that well and seeing the rope ladder that leads down into the darkness, but also hearing some words play around in your head that had been read on a cross-stitching that you had seen up on the second floor in the dining room, and it quoted the book of Genesis, and that cross-stitching said. And the angel of the Lord found her by a fountain of water in the wilderness, by the fountain on the way to Shur. What’s Ezra up to in this moment?

Ezra Merrick

I think after kind of mockingly reading the book and and this the not knowing that it was a legitimate spell in this in this book, but rather reading it as as what he what I would consider to be s some kind of fiction and kind of unconsciously being pulled to the backyard, to the courtyard and seeing this well, what and I I’m I’m getting this sense of something that’s h here, but that I don’t readily perceive. I think I would start to get a little fearful for what is actually possibly happening. what what you know, what else do I see around me in this courtyard? I’m imagining like a a kind of a pergola type thing.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Sure. Sure. you see, I think as we mentioned last time, the plants that had caught Merritt’s attention. I’m not sure to your eye that hasn’t been trained as a botanist that you would pick up on the same skill or patterns that Merritt picked up on in the planting of these various in a sundry green plants and herbs, but I think that you would notice that there’s clearly quite a few of them. Other than that, it seems like a pretty what to you would be typical courtyard for what you would expect to find behind a series of row houses in Philadelphia in the seventeen eighties.

Ezra Merrick

Okay. I think given th this this level of fear that’s starting to set in and make the hair on the back of my neck start to stand up, I would not I would no longer want to be alone. And I will I will start to turn and and make my way back towards is there a back door?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: there’s not actually. The only way to get back to the

Ezra Merrick

Okay.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: courtyard is through that little side door that you came in that’s kind of between the row houses.

Ezra Merrick

ya. I I will I will I will I will turn and just keeping a an an open ear to my surroundings, a little more hypervigilant of my surroundings now that this fear is starting to set in, I’ll I’ll turn and and try to reconvene with everybody else in the house.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Excellent. while Ezra’s been doing all of this, I think that the three of you had noticed g his kind of conspicuous departure from the house. So how are the three of you reacting? What are the three of you saying to one another, if anything?

Dr. Prudence

Well he passed right by like pushed me and Merritt

Ezra Merrick

Yeah.

Dr. Prudence

away from the stairs, right? I think

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: That’s correct, yeah.

Ezra Merrick

Yeah, I would have.

Dr. Prudence

in his haste I would look prudence would look to Merritt. that was peculiar. Are you are you okay? Do you think that that gentleman is okay?

Merritt Vale

No. And Merritt would be somewhat awkward in knowing what else to say, but would kind of make a gesture to Doctor Prudence to maybe that they should walk toward the door, that they should walk toward the way that he left.

Dr. Prudence

Yeah, prudence would like walk down the stairs and pull her the the V of her like dress area down and smooth out her trousers and walk out the door.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: And what’s Captain Ashcroft up to?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

I believe Captain Ashcroft would this is all a confusing time. He was released from prison. He’s a free man, ordered by the people from this house to be here. And he’s arrived and not welcomed. you know, he’s run into these characters. and I think he would Just peruse the house a bit. Not not like searching for anything, but I I think in this moment he’s very contemplative. Is this some sort of ruse? What what is happening here? And I think he would where we all met originally in this you know, this foyer, perhaps, I think that’s where he would. stay, his arms kind of crossed in front of him, and just just search the place for some sort of answer.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Okay. So you’re staying on the first floor then?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Yes. I know they’re trying to leave, but I I don’t feel like I’m pulled there just yet.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I think that you do notice that the bookshelf, which once had four books on it, is down to just a single book. I don’t know if that piques your interest.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

I think something draws him that way.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I think as you find yourself drawn towards the bookshelf, you notice that the name of the book as it appears on the binding is Non-Euclidean Navigation.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

is this strange title? I think he’ll grab it nonchalantly, very like, what is this? You know, you see something at the store and you’re like, I have to read the back of this. What is the what is this about? he’ll he’ll grab it very quickly and open it to the first page.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: So I think that you notice a couple of things about the book immediately. One is that it’s not attributed to any author. However, there is a nameplate in the front cover that kind of indicates that this belonged to one Elias Blake. And It doesn’t really give any other self description in the first page of the book other than this is just for non-Euclidean navigation. And I I am guessing that as a military man yourself, who’s no doubt put some time studying into navigation, you’d be quite taken

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Of course.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: aback by a type of navigation that presumably you’ve never heard of before.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Fascinating. I think he’ll he’ll he’ll just kind of you know, start flipping through the pages, kind of perusing through them and and seeing what strikes.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Excellent, excellent, excellent. Will you give me a quick sanity check on that, Captain Ashcroft? Who saw that coming? Am I right?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

What? That’s crazy. That’s wild. Are you kidding me?

Dr. Prudence

no.

Ezra Merrick

boy, what is it?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

S so so my sanity is eighty one, which I was like, yeah, okay. I rolled no excuse me, my sanity is eighty. I rolled eighty one.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: What have you done since our last episode to Anger the Dice Gods, Captain Croft?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

man, what that’s crazy, bro.

Ezra Merrick

Ha ha ha.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Well, friend, it looks like you’re gonna be losing three sanity points as you thumb through the pages of this book and see diagrams and discussions that just frankly don’t make any sense. I suspect in your boyhood that you were quite adept at geometry and quite adept at navigation. Otherwise you wouldn’t have been able to get your officer’s commission right. But I think that I think that you are just baffled by the diagrams you see before you. you see references to directions that don’t exist in real life. You see things being referenced as being like orthogonal to any direction within the 3D world. You see reference to lines that are ultra parallel, whatever the hell that means. But I think that after giving it more than a cursory glance, there’s something within your heart that doesn’t want to get it, but something within your mind kind of starts to get it. And what we’re gonna say is that you are gonna add a new skill to your character sheet. And that

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Okay.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: skill is. Non-Euclidean navigation. And we’re gonna start you off at 20%. And this skill is gonna be related to finding your way through places that don’t necessarily behave according to the ordinary rules of the three-dimensional or four-dimensional space-time zone that we currently occupy with our consciousness.

Ezra Merrick

captain my captain.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Ha ha ha.

Dr. Prudence

You are my captain now.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

This is nonsense. This is rubbish.

Ezra Merrick

Uh-huh.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: We will see w whether you are able to keep your powder dry when the dimensions spread

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Yeah.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: out beyond the ones we’re used to.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

I think I think he will place the Now question do I keep this book? Is this like like it it would this be something that I might place in my inventory or is this is okay, so all right. So I think

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Absolutely can. You absolutely can.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

I think something like he he places it on the table. He’s like this is hogwash. And he he tosses it down to the table. And something in the back of his mind whispers to him saying, you know, I shouldn’t leave this here. I should. I should have this. And against all of my better judgments, right? Like I I’ve been invited to this house. I’ve been you know I’ve been released from prison, I almost unwillingly am going to. steal from my host.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

And I if I I will slide it into my satchel.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I think something in the back of your head maybe says, Are you stealing? Or was this left here for you intentionally?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Mm-hmm.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Who’s to say? I think, you know, one thing that maybe you picked up on as you were reading through the pages is that there are quite a few marginal notes that are in a very old script, like a very difficult for a modern man such as yourself in the 1780s to be able to to read. But I’m sure that you’ve surmised that those are the marginal notes of one Mr. Elias Blake, the former owner of this book himself. Maybe if you devote a little time to studying it in the weeks to come, you might be able to learn more about those. But for right now, your three new companions have all made their way outside, if I’m not mistaken. Are you lingering in the foyer, Captain Ashcroft? Or are you following them out? What’s the plan here?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

No, I I think this has invigorated him and so he’s like he’ll he’ll follow suit.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: as the three of you exit the front door with Captain Ashcroft following behind Dr. Prudence and Merritt, I think you come crashing into Ezra as he’s heading in the opposite direction trying to get away from the courtyard and perhaps there’s some bumping, perhaps there’s some confusion

Ezra Merrick

yeah.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: in the little very and I cannot stress this enough, very narrow little passageway between the two row homes.

Ezra Merrick

Right. you will you would see Ezra very different than how he left the house in a in a rush, angered. now the color has has mostly left his face and I’m holding the book to my chest kind of d and walking with my head down, very much lost in my own head. yeah, that’s what you see when you walk out.

Merritt Vale

And I would say that Merritt being the first to leave the house to go look for him just bumps s sort of straight into you and both of you both of us kind of collide briefly and back up. And Merritt, who is the thing to know about Merritt, Merritt is is good at noticing people and cares quite a lot, but is just not very good at comfort. And so I look at you and kind of take a look at all of your limbs. Maybe you notice I’m doing that, maybe you don’t, and I say, well you appear to have remained the same shape, so that’s good.

Ezra Merrick

Well, yeah there’s I can’t I can’t explain it. It’s th this can’t be real. But where’s the trick? Th there has to be a trick, right?

Merritt Vale

How are you feeling?

Ezra Merrick

There’s always a trick. Scared. What is this place?

Merritt Vale

And are you are you sure that that’s your feeling?

Ezra Merrick

No.

Merritt Vale

What scared you so much? If it is your feeling, and not the wells, I presume you saw the wells.

Ezra Merrick

I did. Did you see it?

Merritt Vale

Yeah, when I first came in.

Ezra Merrick

There’s something in there. I don’t know what it is, but there’s something there. And I can’t explain it.

Dr. Prudence

while this conversation is happening, Prudence would be standing by and she’s looking for signs of sweat, possibly like elevated heart on him. Would she notice these

Ezra Merrick

Very much so.

Dr. Prudence

things? Yeah.

Ezra Merrick

Yeah. Very but not trying to hide anything now. There there’s no way that I could.

Dr. Prudence

Ezra can can I call you Ezra?

Ezra Merrick

Please, yes.

Dr. Prudence

so as we all know I’m I’m a doctor and it seems that you are very very flushed and that you your heart might be racing. Can I just check your pulse?

Ezra Merrick

sure. What do you need?

Dr. Prudence

can I just have your left hand, please?

Ezra Merrick

and very reluctantly I’ll I’ll peel my hand off the book but still keep it close to my chest and hold my hand out for you.

Dr. Prudence

You’ll notice that Prudence releases like her own hand towards you very kindly. she takes your your l wrist and hand in both of her hands, and she will put her two fingers on top of your wrist and while doing that, she’ll turn your wrist over. So now you have her two fingers on the top right, about two inches above your wrist, and then her

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Yeah.

Dr. Prudence

thumb is right at the the back of your wrist and she’ll start counting and listening and dear Ezra, your heart is very elevated. What what do you mean there is something in the well?

Ezra Merrick

I can’t explain it. There’s in in everything that I’ve done to make a living in this world. I I tell stories, I entertain, I tell people what they need to know. And I can always explain it. But that I can’t explain. I I need somebody to To go with me. I can’t explain it, but I need to know. Does that make sense?

Dr. Prudence

Well science has an explanation. absolutely, but science has an explanation for everything, and I let’s take me to the well. I I I didn’t notice even that there was a well in this alley, so please, take me to the well.

Ezra Merrick

Okay. I will turn and very slowly, reluctantly walk back.

Dr. Prudence

Merritt

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Is it?

Dr. Prudence

will you are Merritt are you gonna stay or do you want to come to the well? Also, where is the captain? And prudence will look around and then look back at merit. Well, shall we?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

he he’s right. He he just peer appears behind you and is like, w we’re back here, I see ya

Dr. Prudence

Hi, Cap Captain Ashcroft. there’s a a situation at the well and Ezra here is very his heart’s palpitating. It’s speeding very quick and we’re all going to go to the well and see what is happening over there. Would you like to join us?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Of course. What’s got

Dr. Prudence

Okay.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

you in a fright, old boy?

Ezra Merrick

I can’t e I can’t explain it. I right but something tells me I need to know what it is.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Lead the way.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: As the four of you

Ezra Merrick

And I do.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: excellent. As the four of you walk back to the well, I think that you peer over the sides and you do see the rope ladder that Ezra saw a moment ago leading down down. But now with the four of you gathered here, you see something that Ezra did not see when it was just him standing by the well. And that something is just the faintest glow of what looks to be candlelight coming from somewhere down in the depths of the well.

Ezra Merrick

Is it anything reminiscent of the candle that I’ve seen in the window?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I think that you can’t help but shake the feeling that it is the same candle, Ezra.

Ezra Merrick

seeing this, I will I’ll open the book again. and flip through a few pages until I see what I want to read or what’s calling to me what I want to read and kinda just put my my hand, my finger up to the words and follow along. And read by breath restrained, by eye unclouded, by silence made still. Let the veil grow thin, let no shadow conceal its master, let no hunger pass unnamed, let no will move unseen. Reveal the nature of this thing before me. Reveal its want. Reveal its intent. Be known. And I’ll slam the book shut.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: And how I’m gonna rule on that is that you’re still not maybe within range or within eyesight or hearing distance or whatever you wanna call it of whatever it is that’s causing that sense of presence down in the well. But what I do think, Ezra, is that you perceive that the candlelight down in the well gives an energetic pulse when you finish the spell. I’m not gonna charge you your magic points or your sanity for that because of our

Ezra Merrick

Alright.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: continued presence outside of range, but you do see that pulse of a brighter, more energetic light coming from the candle down in the well.

Ezra Merrick

seeing that all kinda Did you see it? Did you see that?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Whoa whoa e easy there, Briggs. It’s all right.

Ezra Merrick

You mean to tell me none of you saw that? Did do any of you see it right now?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I think the other three see the candlelight, but it they definitely missed that energetic pulse that made itself perceptible to you, Ezra.

Dr. Prudence

Well, it does seem that there might be a a flicker that was dropped. does prudence know that there’s water in this well? Is this well dried up? I mean

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Hard to say from your vantage point right now.

Dr. Prudence

It it seems like maybe somebody just dropped a candle, Ezra, and that it’s that it’s nothing. I mean there’s n so many people that have been around. Does she notice?

Ezra Merrick

I certainly hope that’s true.

Dr. Prudence

she’s gonna put her hands on the well. and she’s not short. She’s definitely not Alicia short. She’s probably like five eight, you know. I don’t know if that was tall for a lady back in the seventeen hundreds, but like

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I think that’s skyscraper from the

Ezra Merrick

Tall for Alicia.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: seventeen eighties. Yeah.

Dr. Prudence

Wait, is it really tall for seventeen eighty for a woman? Are they short like me?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I yeah. I I I will double check myself before I go spreading my anachronism along, you know, around the entire internet. But I am pretty sure that five eight would have been towering in the seventeen eighties.

Dr. Prudence

Well, she’s not towering. She’s just not short. So she’s not Alicia and so and she’s definitely not Seth, because Seth

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah.

Dr. Prudence

is very tall. He doesn’t look it, but Seth is a very tall human. I literally go up to like his belly button. He’s very tall. so like,

Ezra Merrick

Can confirm.

Dr. Prudence

okay, so she’s like of average size, 1780, female stature. She wears men’s shoes, so she’s got like a little baby heel, nothing big. but she’s gonna lean over. The well and put her arms on it and kinda hoist herself up like you know, like up and then lean. She’s gonna lean over the well and say, I don’t I don’t know what you saw or didn’t see, but it just looks like a and she’ll lean a little further and a little further. It just looks like a a well. Yeah, it just looks like a well. And she’s just staring with her head in the fucking well.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Please be careful, doctor Prudence.

Dr. Prudence

Aye, Captain. Aye.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I think that as you’re leaning over and making all of us very nervous, Dr. Prudence, I think that you do maybe knock a pebble off of the ledge or something along those lines. And after a very long second or two, you do hear a slight splash in the water below. So you are now both seeing the candlelight and hearing the splash of the water.

Dr. Prudence

dear Ezra you know there was wo

Ezra Merrick

What what what do you see?

Dr. Prudence

as he says that she’s gonna like scamper back up

Ezra Merrick

I I’ll kinda help you back stand up.

Dr. Prudence

Did you know there was water in the well? Did anybody know that there was water in the well? There’s a there’s a candle down there and there’s water in the well.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

It is well.

Dr. Prudence

Mm yeah, but there’s a Yes, but there’s a there’s a candle in the water that’s still in this well.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Yeah.

Dr. Prudence

I’m just gonna look at Merritt and look at Ezra

Ezra Merrick

after No go ahead.

Dr. Prudence

and look at Captain Ashcroft. There’s water. And then like dead ass stare at Merritt. There’s water in the well. And instantly she just kinda like dumbfounded. I’m stuck on water in the well. Stuck.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Just she’s just stuck she’s just stuck saying it over and over. Yeah.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: You you’re making me want to make you roll for sanity on this, but I won’t.

Merritt Vale

Yeah.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

I think we all should roll for sanity. I think we’re all going a little crazy. yes, water in the well. I think I I think I think Captain Ashcroft would be like Yes. Doctor, yes, there’s water in the well. But after all Most wells have water. That said, most wells don’t have candles. Most wells do not have ladders leaning down leading down into them.

Merritt Vale

And Merritt is going to be looking at Dr. Prudence with the most they can muster of concern. but as all of this has been happening, they’ve been thinking about and Ryan, can can we see the candle in the upstairs from where we are? That’s only from the front of the house, right? That we see the candle, but the candle was there.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I don’t think that you see the candle there anymore. I think that that was something that was observed especially by Ezra at night as he was scooping the house before everyone else arrived. I think possibly if you had arrived at night you might have seen that in the window, but I’m not sure that any of the three of you saw that other than Ezra, and I for sure know that none of the four of you see it in the window right now.

Merritt Vale

Okay. So Merritt is particularly disturbed by the candle down there. but they’ve been pr playing that close to the vest as this confusion has unfolded, and they ask the group, has anyone seen a candle anywhere else?

Ezra Merrick

I have.

Merritt Vale

Where?

Ezra Merrick

So I I’ve been here for a few days now and I key I’ve I’ve seen a candle in the in the window up on the second floor but ever since we’ve been here I haven’t been able to find it. But maybe it’s down there now. And there’s something that I can’t keep out of my mind now about a fountain of water in the wilderness. Are are an is anybody here religious in any way? ‘Cause I’m not.

Merritt Vale

So Merritt is actually not even listening anymore because they’re starting to really be stuck on something and they’re thinking about the candle that Ezra’s describing and they’re thinking about the candle in the well and what’s coming into their mind is as above, so below, over and over, as above, so below, as above, so below. And they look to the group and they say, I don’t like the symmetry of this. This kind of symmetry doesn’t exist in the natural world. Humans do this. So I’m wondering if the rope ladder is an invitation.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: How do the rest of you respond to this?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

I concur with Vale here. This house is full of strangeness and Well it seems to be calling to us one way or another. And he looks at Ezra. I say, nothing vintage, nothing gained. And you see, he begins to kind of like roll up his his pant leg. and if no one begins to stop him, he’s going to swing a leg over. he’ll be kind of sitting on the edge of the well. and he’ll say, He’ll look at all of you and he’ll say, I’ll be right back. And as he begins to

Ezra Merrick

I’ll go.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

swing his other leg over and and start to climb down, some may hear a whisper of him saying, Keep your powder dry, old boy As he whispers to himself. Yeah.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Gonna be tough to do in a well, I’m afraid.

Ezra Merrick

I will I will tuck I will tuck the grimoire in my vest and whisper to myself, but I g I guess loud enough for for people close to him to hear us seems I’m following an ambitious captain yet again. And I’ll follow suit.

Dr. Prudence

Did anybody hear that or is it just under Ezra’s f like breath?

Ezra Merrick

I would kinda mutter it to myself, like if you hear somebody talking to themselves in a certain way.

Dr. Prudence

Prudence is right next to him. Would she have clocked it, Ryan?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I think so.

Dr. Prudence

Thank you.

Merritt Vale

Merit’s going to follow, tapping the breast pocket of their shirt where their specimen is. And they’re gonna follow.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Are we four for four then headed down the rope ladder?

Dr. Prudence

yeah, like just like I lived my life, like a candle in the well, I’m going.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah, that’s that’s really beautiful. You

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Like a candle in the well

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: should write that down and and get some get

Ezra Merrick

Can’t afford that.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: get some IP rights on that before anyone else does.

Dr. Prudence

I are I wrote it in chatted th two minutes ago.

Ezra Merrick

Th three seconds is fair use, that’s fine.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

I didn’t see it.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Okay, well friends, well, see what I did there. You find yourselves climbing down and down. Further and further and further. And just when you think it can’t possibly go on any longer, you reach the bottom of the rope ladder and you find yourself standing in ankle deep water. Enough’s there to be obnoxious as you get your shoes completely soaked, but definitely not enough there to you know, be retrieving buckets full of water from this well. you look up and you see what appears to be the end of what would be the man-made part of this well, and you see an opening up into what appears to be a natural cavern. The water kind of leads you canal like into this cavern. but there’s something at the entrance of this cavern that I think for reasons I’ll explain in a moment, is gonna cause our friend Ezra to do a sanity roll. Ezra, would you mind giving me that sanity roll before I let you in on the why?

Ezra Merrick

I I would love to. Let me pull up ye old character sheet. Now, since I’ve lost sanity, do I go off my current?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: You do go off your current score, not your max, yep. Or not your starting, I should say.

Ezra Merrick

Gotcha, okay. twenty.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Okay, okay. you are only gonna lose one point of sanity then we’ll cut it in half.

Ezra Merrick

Yes. All right.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: and what you see that unsettles you so deeply Is that at the entrance of this cavern, you see a little end table. And perched atop the end table is the candle that you are 100% certain now was the candle you saw in the second story window while you were scooping the house. But next to the candle is what really troubles you now, because what’s next to the candle on this little end table is a plate. Now that plate looks like it had once been shattered, but it’s been glued back together now. And I think that as you nervously go up to look at the plate that

Ezra Merrick

Yes.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: you you have a growing sense of conviction was the plate that you broke, you pick it up. it says something a little bit different now. Instead of saying as above,

Ezra Merrick

What does it say?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: so below, now it reads As below so above.

Ezra Merrick

This this can’t be right. This I’ve and I’ll I’ll hold it up to everybody else and when I hold it up does it stay together? Okay. I I

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Indeed, indeed it does.

Ezra Merrick

I hold it up and say I broke this inside. How is it here?

Dr. Prudence

You mean that you is that what you were is that what you threw when we were upstairs in the dining area?

Ezra Merrick

It it was. I I must admit I

Dr. Prudence

That’s right.

Ezra Merrick

I let my frustration get the better of me. But I’m very much sure.

Dr. Prudence

Are you sure? Are you absolutely sure?

Ezra Merrick

Yes, doctor, I am very sure. There’s few things that I’m not very sure of in my life other than what’s happening right now. But if I’m convicted in anything right now is that I broke this plate. Look, you can see the p spots where I broke it.

Dr. Prudence

does she notice those things, Ryan?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah, I think it’s pretty obvious if you look at the plate that it had once been shattered and then glued back together.

Dr. Prudence

Okay, Prudence is gonna look at you, Ezra, and with her like most bedside manner voice and arm, she’s gonna lean in and Ezra It’s not possible for this to have been broken inside the house and then make its way down the stairs and down the street. Into a well and be unbroken. It doesn’t make any sense. And you are positive.

Ezra Merrick

We’re in agreement. Yes. I I can’t explain it, much like everything else that’s happened tonight, and I feel like I’m starting to lose my sanity bit by bit.

Dr. Prudence

She pinches in between her nose and looks to the other two. This this is nothing I have ever seen before. Merritt, do you know anything about this possibility or Captain Ashcroft, is there anything that you could possibly see that this could be something that has happened? And then she just looks. at the water and bends down and goes to put her hand in the water as she hangs on that question to merit and Captain Ashcroft.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah, the water is cool to the touch, and like I said, it’s about ankle deep, so not super deep, but it appears to be coming from that cavern. and the cavern does, like I said, appear to stretch out into a tunnel leading away from behind the table, the end table with the candle and the plate on it, and away from the entrance of the well.

Ezra Merrick

I reach out and try to grab the candle. Can I pick it up?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: You sure can.

Ezra Merrick

Okay. And I’ll hold it up and I’ll see that the cavern continues on. Do I see anything now that I hold this candle up and have more light in the area? Do I what do I see?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I think that you just see that it goes on for a ways.

Ezra Merrick

Gotcha.

Dr. Prudence

And Merritt Ashcroft, any thoughts? Per prudence is just staring at you.

Merritt Vale

I think Merritt would say I’m not ready to assume an extraordinary cause if we haven’t exhausted the ordinary ones first. And they start to look around the cavern and evidently they can also see that beyond the table is more space. Ryan, is there anything else Merritt might notice in these circumstances as they look beyond where the table is, toward wherever that cavern leads, up the walls, just trying to assess maybe the age of the cave, whether anyone had recently been there or there was any evidence of that.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: That’s a great question. and I will let you decide, depending on where your focus is, whether you are gonna roll this as a spot hidden or as something related more to your scientific knowledge. So you tell me more what what Merritt is focusing on in the moment and we’ll go from there on the roll.

Merritt Vale

Okay, so I think Merritt would be looking for some kind of logical explanation here. and part of what they would be assessing for is is there anything growing down here? How long does it appear the table has been here? Is there anything on or around the table that might have found its way there to indicate a timestamp? And they might be using their knowledge of botany specifically to look for any kind of vegetation along the cave walls. Are they Are there places where things might be growing through the brick? yeah, that’s the kind of stuff they’d probably be looking at.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah, let’s do that as a natural world rule then.

Merritt Vale

Let me pull up my character sheet. Taking notes. All right.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah. And as I recall, your natural world score is pretty high. So you

Merritt Vale

Yeah, it is.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: get a 75 there, right?

Merritt Vale

And I roll a ninety six.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Oof. Okay.

Merritt Vale

No

Ezra Merrick

Cheese.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: I think that even though this cave does appear to be natural, for some reason there’s just something about it you can’t really figure out. I think that there doesn’t appear to be any plant life or anything like that, at least not where you’re at at the moment. which I think confounds you a little bit, because I think that you were supposing that where there’s water, there’s some sort of plant. growth, right? but beyond that I think that you just see the tunnel leading on into the darkness.

Merritt Vale

Then Merritt will continue to be fucking confused.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Yes, some sort of logical explanation. I I agree with you, Vale. perhaps I mean there were many plates made, I’m sure several have been broken. Perhaps this is just part of some sort of test to throw you off your balance.

Ezra Merrick

Captain, are you religious man? ’cause I’m I’m I can’t be can’t help but see a resemblance to something that the people of this house took quite a liking to is a there was a a Bible verse that they had sewn into their decorations upstairs. I don’t know if you saw it or not, but it spoke of a a fountain in the wilderness and we just climbed in one But I’m unsure of what sure is. Is this a location referenced in the Bible that you would know of?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Why yes. Sure is a desert, is it not?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah, and I think Captain Ashcroft, if you wanna give me a a no roll, a K N O W on that with just your education stat, we can decide

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Right.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: what else you know about this here Bible verse.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

That is a one.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Well now, said

Ezra Merrick

Alright.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Impressive even by your elevated standards, Captain Ashcroft, because that one, of course, is a critical success for any role, but especially given that your education is at a 90, goodness, a well-educated gentleman such as yourself, Captain Ashcroft, would surely have studied the King James Bible at some length in your boyhood, and would have no doubt countless times Come across the passage in Genesis 16 that tells a story that would be troubling to our modern ears today in 2026, maybe slightly less so to the ears of 1784, but it’s the story of Hagar. It’s the story of a woman who was a slave to a woman named Sarah. Sarah, of course, being the wife of Abraham. And it tells the story of Hagar, who was given over to Abraham by his wife Sarah, to bear him a son, in the absence of Sarah’s ability to do so herself. And you would know that after Sarah grew jealous of Hagar for burying Ishmael to Abraham, that The account in Genesis says that Hagar was banished from Abraham’s camp and found her way into the desert, where the well that we are discussing at some length here would have been referenced, or the fountain as it’s rendered in the King James Version. How does everybody respond to that?

Ezra Merrick

I assume y that that’s what you explained to me, Captain?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Sorry, yeah, I was trying to find a a better way to do it. But yes, essentially, you know, I

Ezra Merrick

No, you’re good.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

I will repeat, I’ll basically give the cliff notes of the story.

Ezra Merrick

Well, that sounds sounds intense. Well, it seems if this is where we’re meant to be for our so called initiation. Let’s see if anything else of note here should we push forward?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: If all four of you are pushing forward into the cavern, I assume. As you walk into the cavern, you probably go about fifty yards, not able to see too far ahead of you with the light of this candle that Ezra is holding. But you come to, well, I was gonna call it a fork in the road, but it would be hard to describe it as such because the tines of this fork bend in directions that you hadn’t previously thought possible. One might even describe them as non Euclidean directions, correct?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Nah, there it is.

Ezra Merrick

Ayy.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: But you f as best you can tell the fork splits into two and a half directions. I’m not going to explain that any further. And if someone with a non Euclidean navigation skill wanted to roll against that to see if he could discern a path, I would certainly invite him to do so at this time.

Ezra Merrick

I’ll be holding the candle up leading the way and see this and very visibly confused turn. I I’m I have no idea what’s going on. which way do we go?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

As Captain Ashcroft takes the lead, this pathway, like you said, it’s it’s not quite two, it’s two and a half forks. It’s it’s hard to explain. And I think as he he l looks th the pages in the book in his mind begin to flip and turn, and a migraine. begins to press against the front of his brain as he almost feels nauseous, faint, sick, weak in the in the knees. someone might notice as he kind of starts to sway a bit looking for the answers in his brain but also looking into this unexplainable cavern and I rolled a 58

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Yeah. you’re new to this non-Euclidean navigation thing. It’s all right. We all, you know, take some time to adjust to our new skills. but I think that, you know, despite that massive migraine that you’re feeling, and who amongst us wouldn’t feel the same migraine in the situation, I think even through the pain, you get the sense that it’s the part of the fork that goes upward but not northward. That’s the one that you should follow. Upward not northward. No, that that one’s northward not upward.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

I think he would l literally say that n perhaps we’ll go upward. Not the northward path, but the upward path.

Ezra Merrick

And how would one do that, Captain?

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Well, you make sure you’ll t you take the upward one, not the northern one.

Ezra Merrick

Right. And I’ll

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

No.

Ezra Merrick

I’ll just try to start to approach this path that is upward, not northward.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

No no that is the northern one.

Ezra Merrick

Sorry, sorry, sorry. That perhaps you should lead the way then.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Course. And he’ll kind of readjust the pain kind of leaving his his brain. he’ll fix his jacket and he’ll begin to walk toward the upward path.

Ezra Merrick

Ezra will shake

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Excellent.

Ezra Merrick

his head and and think to himself, officers

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Ha ha ha.

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

It’s like

Merritt Vale

I think Merritt would be laughing to themselves because they’ve descended to take an upward path and they’re finding that very funny.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: As you take this path that goes upward, not northward. You take a few steps in that direction, you round a few impossible corners. You find yourself going back downward but not southward, mind you. Then you come into a room. Filled as always with water up to the ankles, and lying face down in this ankle deep water, you see what appears to be four bodies. And that is where we will pick up next time here on the Palim Cess Society.

Ezra Merrick

are any of them wearing a very dapper vest?

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Well you

Capt. Edmund Ashcroft

Well we don’t know yet.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: will have to find that out yourself next episode,

Ezra Merrick

I wanna know.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: Mr. Merrick.

Dr. Prudence

Yeah.

Ryan – Keeper of Arcane Lore: friends, if you have not yet completed your social media ritual and followed us at the Palim Cess Society, we would invite you to do so. And until next time, keep your powder dry.

Initiation- Arrival Ep 1